So Young, So Great: Bob Feller Electrifies Baseball and America
Jim Ingraham/University of Nebraska Press/June 2026/280pp/IBSN: 9781496245595

Before Bob Feller became Bob Feller, he was Bobby Feller, son of Bill Feller of Van Meter, IA, a small farming town of 360 souls. From infancy, his father Bill nurtured his son’s interest in and obvious talent for baseball. As Ingraham writes, “He hit the ground throwing, not running.” From the age of one, Bobby and his dad played catch three times a day every day for 12 years. By the age of eight, he was throwing curveballs. But that was not enough for Bill. To develop and showcase his son’s athletic gifts, when Bobby was 13 they built a real-life Field of Dreams and formed their own team. Father and son leveled the farm’s pastureland and fenced it to keep out the livestock. Bill bought all the necessary equipment, including real baseball bases to field his team, Oakview. A few years later, when Bobby began playing for his high school team, he pitched five no-hitters, and some local schools would not schedule games with Van Meter High until Feller graduated. So young, so great.

All of this was bound to attract the attention of major league scouts, and it did, but not before the Dream Teen was discovered by … an umpire. Which one exactly is still open to debate. The two who claimed credit for finding Feller had both been behind the plate at games he pitched in the summer of 1935 for The Farmers Union, a semipro team in the American Association. Both were blown away by what they saw. Both got in touch with the Cleveland Indians about Feller.

Whoever got there first, the result was the same. A few weeks after the team heard about the teen phenom, Cy Slapnicka, the Indians’ GM, rode out to the Feller farm to talk with Bill and Bobby. And a week after that, Bobby became Bob Feller, signing a major league baseball contract in the family’s kitchen. Among other clauses, it contained these:

• The Fargo club agrees to allow Robert to visit his folks at any time during the 1936 season at the expense of the club.
• The Fargo club has no objection to Robert playing basketball at any time.
• For consideration of $1 paid to Robert Feller this agreement is declared valid.

The contract had to be cosigned by Bill since Bob was a minor. Feller did not disappoint.

The summary of statistics for his first four years begins with this: On September 13, 1936, at the age of 17, he threw a two-hit complete game for the Cleveland Indians and set an American League record for strikeouts with 17. In other words, as the author points out, he struck out his age. Three weeks later he went back to Van Meter to start his senior year of high school. In his first four MLB seasons, Feller hit the 1,000 strikeout mark sooner than Walter Johnson, Christy Mathewson, or Grover Cleveland Alexander did in their first FIVE seasons. And in that span, he pitched between 200-500 fewer innings.

By the age of 22, Feller had won 105 games. At that same age, Lefty Grove, Carl Hubbell, Cy Young, Randy Johnson, Warren Spahn, Bob Gibson, Grover Cleveland Alexander, Sandy Koufax, Roger Clemens, Nolan Ryan, Tom Seaver, Greg Maddux, Tom Glavine, Juan Marichal, Justin Verlander, Jim Bunning, Max Scherzer, and Phil Niekro COMBINED had won 105. So young, so great.

All of this played out in a different era, of course. When Bob Feller burst onto the baseball scene, the game was truly the great American pastime. His prodigious, precocious talent inspired the kind of fanaticism today reserved for tech bros and pop stars. During spring training in 1937, the Sporting News wrote that “Bob Feller, 18-years old and still working for his high school diploma, will open the season as the greatest drawing card in baseball.” That same year he became only the second baseball player to appear on the cover of Time magazine. The first was Babe Ruth. Later that spring his high school graduation was broadcast live on national radio.

Feller’s dominance mesmerized not only sportswriters, but fans as well, inspiring a 1930s-style moneyball mania among team owners. He was such an outsized draw that teams schemed to maximize attendance by clever scheduling of his starts. With good reason. In 1936, average attendance at Red Sox home games was 8,141. When Feller pitched it jumped to 21,000. At home in Cleveland, attendance for Feller’s starts throughout that fall was more than double the average gate. So young, so golden.

Ingraham states at the beginning that the book is focused on Feller’s early career before he went to serve in WWII, and that alone is a remarkable story. But the book is also a love letter to the great game of baseball. His fluid prose at times soars like that of A Lefty’s Legacy, Jane Leavy’s tribute to Sandy Koufax. Ingraham describes the teenage Feller: “The Iowa farm boy was laying new track across the major league landscape—track never imagined much less ridden.” Every baseball fan will want to board this train. It’s one helluva ride.

***

Reviewer Jo Ann Zimmerman is a long-time educator, sports fan, and Philadelphia native. She has written for a variety of publications including Cleaver Magazine and Tupelo Quarterly Review. Her wedding song was Take Me out to the Ballgame and she will greet you in the Wawa with Go Birds.